How to fill out a report
Use Witness statement for something you experienced. Use Background / case history for historic cases, folklore, and research (for example the Brown Lady or the Bridgewater Triangle) when you are not a firsthand or secondhand witness. Short summary is required on every submission — a few sentences visitors will see first. Original statements are preserved as submitted. Do not include precise addresses, they stay private.
- Short summary — Required. A brief public blurb for cards, lists, and the top of the case page.
- Background / case history — Place history, folklore, prior reports, and the full historic narrative. Required for Historical and Research source types. Shown publicly whenever it is filled, including alongside a witness statement.
- Witness statement — Your own firsthand account. Required for Firsthand submissions. Leave blank for historic cases you did not witness.
- Secondhand account — Something told to you by someone else. Not for published history or folklore — that goes in Background.
On existing cases if you want to add to the case select the "Contribute to Case" button and select the proper option and submit the files or data in question. If you find a factual error in the summary or background and want to submit a correction use 'Correction/Update' in the pull down menu options.
Source type
Source type tells us where the account comes from, not how believable it is. It is not a grade. Documentation strength is recorded separately as a rating from A to E, and that rating judges the paperwork, never the witness.
- Firsthand — You were there and you are describing what you personally saw, heard, felt, or recorded. Put the full account in Witness statement. This is the most useful kind of report, because we can ask you follow-up questions.
- Secondhand — Someone else had the experience and you are passing it along. Please name who told you and your relationship to them in the secondhand account field. Reporting for a friend or relative who will not come forward is welcome.
- Historical — A documented case from the past rather than your own experience: an old newspaper account, a local legend with a paper trail, a known haunting or disappearance. Put the full narrative in Background (required). Include sources or links where you can. Leave Witness statement blank unless you also have a personal encounter to add.
- Research — Your own investigation or analysis instead of an experience: records and archive work, site visit notes, photo or audio analysis, historical context, or a conventional explanation you have tested. Put the write-up in Background (required). Use this when you are adding to the record rather than reporting an event.
- Evidence only — You have a photograph, recording, video, or document but little or no story to go with it. You cannot say what happened, only what was captured. This lets the material enter the archive without anyone inventing a narrative around it. Still include a short summary of how you acquired it, any history of it you do know and chain of custody to the best of your knowledge.
Phenomenon tags
Tick every tag that applies. Most genuine reports touch more than one: a dark figure in a hallway that also panicked the dog and left a scratch is three tags, not one. Tags are how visitors find related files and how we group cases for the show, so accuracy helps more than tidiness. On the archive list, the phenomenon filter and the tag buttons under the stats strip use these same labels.
- Apparitions & Spirits — Human-seeming figures, whole or partial. Covers full-body apparitions, transparent or solid forms, faces and torsos, recognizable deceased people, crisis apparitions at the moment of a death, repeating scenes that play out the same way, and shaped mists.
- Shadow Entities & Dark Figures — Dark, featureless humanoid shapes that seem to swallow light rather than reflect it. Separate from apparitions because there is no face, clothing, or detail. Covers shadow people, the hat man, dark masses in doorways, and figures at the edge of vision that are gone when you look straight at them.
- Physical & Poltergeist Activity — Anything that moves, strikes, or interferes with the physical world. Covers objects thrown or relocated, doors and cabinets opening, knocking and rapping, footsteps with impact, electrical and appliance interference, lights cycling, objects appearing from nowhere, and marks left on furniture or walls.
- UFOs/UAPs — Unidentified craft, objects, or lights in the sky, on the water, or under it. Covers structured craft, light formations, silent triangles, distant orbs, instrument and radar anomalies, close encounters, landing traces, and occupant sightings.
- Cryptids & Unknown Zoology — Animals that should not be there, or should not exist. Covers upright hominids such as bigfoot or sasquatch, dogmen and upright canids, lake and river creatures, thunderbirds and winged humanoids, out-of-place big cats, and physical sign such as tracks, hair, scat, or unusual kills.
- Auditory & Acoustic Events — Sound with no source you can locate. Covers voices and whispers, your name being called, footsteps in empty rooms, music or singing, unexplained booms and hums, phantom animal sounds, and anomalies captured on a recorder.
- Spatiotemporal Anomalies (Missing Time) — Distortions of time, distance, or place. Covers lost or missing time, a familiar drive that took far too long or too little, sudden dead silence, roads that repeat or refuse to arrive, rooms and doorways that do not match the building, abrupt displacement, and apparent slips into another era.
- Consciousness & Altered States — Experiences seated in perception and awareness rather than the room around you. Covers sleep paralysis and bedroom visitors, out-of-body and near-death experiences, precognitive or shared dreams, premonition and telepathy, and encounters during trance, meditation, or ritual.
- Physiological & Biological Effects — What the body recorded. Covers unexplained paralysis, scratches, bruises/burns, or punctures; nausea, headaches, and nosebleeds; sudden cold or heat with no source; pressure on the chest; lasting illness or medical findings after an encounter; and animals in distress.
- Folklore & Cultural Encounters — Experiences that follow an established regional or cultural pattern. Covers fae and little people, black dogs, la Llorona, the wendigo, djinn, roadside and bridge legends, cursed ground and fairy paths, and seasonal or local traditions tied to a place.
- Religious & Spiritual Manifestations — Encounters understood in religious or spiritual terms. Covers angels and demons, possession and oppression, apparitions of Mary or the saints, weeping or bleeding statues, stigmata, healing, deliverance and exorcism, and experiences at sacred sites.
- Unclassified & Other — For anything that does not fit, or that you would rather not force into a box. Also the right choice when an experience spans several categories and none of them are fully accurate. An honest unclassified file is worth more to us than a confident wrong label.
Documentation rating
Every published file carries a letter from A to E. Staff assign it during review, so it is not something you choose when you submit. On a case page you can expand Rating to read the key. Read it carefully, because it is narrower than it looks: the letter rates the documentation, not the witness and not whether anything paranormal happened. A sincere, detailed account from one person with nothing to corroborate it still rates a D, and that is not an accusation. A well-documented hoax could rate an A on paperwork alone. A famous regional legend with many stories but only newspapers and later interviews typically rates a C.
- A — Strong dossier: several independent sources plus primary evidence (original media, records, measurements) a researcher could use without interviewing anyone.
- B — Well documented: multiple independent witnesses with at least some contemporary primary material, or one witness with substantial primary corroboration such as photographs, recordings, contemporaneous notes, or documents.
- C — Multi-source but soft: several witnesses or a long run of reports, but mostly testimony and after-the-fact secondary sources (newspapers, folklore collections, later interviews). Little or no primary physical evidence. Regional legend clusters such as the Bridgewater Triangle land here.
- D — Thin: a single witness (or one household) with little or no support beyond the account. The most common rating for a sincere personal experience, and a perfectly normal place for a file to sit.
- E — Incomplete or not yet assessed. Every new submission starts here until staff have read it, so an E often just means “not yet assessed” rather than “rejected.”
A rating can go up. If you send us follow-up detail, a photograph you found later, or a second witness comes forward, the file is re-reviewed and the change is recorded in its history.
Investigation status
Investigation status tells you where a case currently sits in the archive's research lifecycle. It does not indicate whether Gothic.Black believes a paranormal explanation is true. Status may change as new reports, sources, evidence, or research become available.
- Open — The file has been accepted into the archive and remains open for research, contributions, corrections, or additional evidence. There may be unresolved questions, but no active investigation is currently underway.
- Active — The phenomenon is still producing documented activity. For recurring phenomena, Gothic.Black generally expects at least one sufficiently documented event within the last 10 years before treating the phenomenon as Active.
- Archived — The file is retained as part of the archive but is no longer being actively developed. This may include cases whose research has stalled, cases retained primarily for historical/reference purposes, or files superseded by a better-organized record. Archived does not mean disproved.
- Resolved — The central question of the case has been answered to a reasonable evidentiary standard. A resolved case may have a conventional, fraudulent, mistaken, paranormal, or other explanation. Resolution describes the state of the investigation, not a preferred kind of answer.
- Historic — The principal events belong to the past and no continuing modern activity is sufficiently documented. Historic cases remain open to better sources, corrections, and research even though the reported event or wave has ended.
Important: Historic, Resolved, and Archived mean different things. A 1725 vampire panic can be Historic but unresolved as to what caused the deaths. A photographic anomaly can be Resolved if the object is conclusively identified. An incomplete or superseded file can be Archived without its underlying mystery being resolved.
Date occurred vs. Activity Period
Date occurred and Activity Period answer different questions and should not be forced to match.
Date occurred
Use Date occurred for the public date of a specific incident or clearly defined event.
Examples:
- A UFO encounter that occurred on
1977-04-25
- A photograph taken during an observation on
1968-08-18
- A single reported apparition on a known date
For a long-running haunting, recurring folklore tradition, multi-year investigation, or historical wave without one defining event, Date occurred may properly be left blank.
Activity Period
Activity Period describes the chronology of the phenomenon or case as a whole.
- Earliest claimed event — The earliest event the tradition or witnesses claim occurred. This can predate surviving documentation.
- Earliest documented report — The earliest report for which Gothic.Black currently has traceable historical documentation. A claimed event in 1925 does not become a documented 1925 report merely because a book published in 1966 says it happened in 1925.
- Latest documented report — The latest presently documented occurrence belonging to the phenomenon. Use
Ongoing when sufficiently documented reports continue rather than inventing an ending date.
- Pattern — Describes the overall shape of the activity, such as a single event, recurring phenomenon, or historic wave.
Date qualifiers
When the editor provides a separate qualifier such as Circa, Early, or Late, keep the date itself clean and put the uncertainty in the qualifier.
For example:
1727 + Circa
rather than entering:
c. 1727
Likewise, if the historical evidence only establishes the year 1981, enter 1981. Do not manufacture 1981-01-01 simply because the database accepts a complete date.
It is completely acceptable for these fields to remain Unknown when the evidence does not establish a responsible date. Unknown is information about the state of the record, not an error that needs to be filled.
Evidence & Media provenance
Provenance tells readers how securely Gothic.Black can establish what a photograph, recording, document, video, or other media item actually is and where it came from. It does not certify the paranormal interpretation shown or claimed in the material.
- Verified — The origin and relevant context of the item can be established from a reliable source. Examples include an original newspaper photograph with a photographer credit, an official document from an identifiable archive, or a photograph whose creator, date, and relationship to the case can be independently established. A verified photograph of a reported witness verifies the photograph and its provenance, not that a paranormal attack occurred.
- Attributed — The item has a plausible and meaningful attribution, but some part of its provenance remains unconfirmed. Examples include a historical photograph consistently attributed to a case but lacking the original photographer or date, or a modern photograph proposed as an incident location through careful geolocation but not confirmed by an authoritative record.
- Unverified — The item is associated with the case but Gothic.Black cannot presently establish its origin, date, creator, chain of custody, or relationship to the event well enough to rely upon it. Unverified material may remain in the archive when documenting the history of a claim is itself useful, but its uncertainty should be stated clearly.
Provenance is not authenticity of the paranormal claim. A newspaper clipping can be Verified even when the story printed in it is disputed. A clear photograph can be Attributed if nobody can establish who took it. A laboratory result is only as useful as the chain of custody connecting the tested material to the case. When provenance cannot be established, describe exactly what is known rather than upgrading the item because it appears plausible.
Credibility note: Ed Warren and Lorraine Warren were influential paranormal investigators, but their methods, degree of involvement, and accounts have been materially disputed in several prominent cases. Writer Ray Garton stated that Ed Warren encouraged invention or embellishment while developing the Snedeker narrative, and other investigators and participants have challenged aspects of the Warrens’ versions of events. Gothic.Black therefore treats Warren-originated paranormal conclusions as disputed claims requiring independent corroboration.