Gothic.Black · Paranormal Files

Case File Database

← All cases

GG-2026-042

Amityville House

  • Phenomenon Apparitions & Spirits, Shadow Entities & Dark Figures, Auditory & Acoustic Events
  • Documentation
    Rating B
    • A — Strong dossier: several independent sources plus primary evidence (original media, records, measurements) a researcher could use without interviewing anyone.
    • B — Well documented: multiple independent witnesses with at least some contemporary primary material, or one witness with substantial primary corroboration (photos, recordings, contemporaneous notes, documents).
    • C — Multi-source but soft: several witnesses or a long run of reports, but mostly testimony and after-the-fact secondary sources (newspapers, folklore collections, later interviews). Little or no primary physical evidence. Regional legend clusters such as the Bridgewater Triangle land here.
    • D — Thin: single witness (or one household), little or no support beyond the account. Normal for a sincere personal experience.
    • E — Incomplete or not yet assessed. Every new submission starts here until staff have read it.
  • Evidence & media 2 items
  • Status Historic
  • Location Amityville, New York · exact location withheld
  • Occurred 13 November 1974

This case is associated with private or restricted property. Do not trespass, disturb residents, remove artifacts, or conduct an investigation without explicit permission.

The residence is private property and should be viewed only from public areas. Please respect residents and local regulations.

Activity period

  • Earliest claimed event 18 December 1975
  • Earliest documented report 1976
  • Latest documented report 14 January 1976
  • Pattern Historic wave

Summary

On November 13, 1974, Ronald DeFeo Jr. murdered six members of his family inside their home at 112 Ocean Avenue in Amityville, New York. He was convicted the following year. In December 1975, George Lutz, Kathleen Lutz, and Kathleen's three children moved into the house, only to leave 28 days later after reporting a series of frightening experiences. Their story became the basis of The Amityville Horror, the 1977 bestseller by Jay Anson. The haunting claims later became deeply controversial: former DeFeo attorney William Weber said that elements of the story had been devised with the Lutzes, while the Lutzes continued to maintain that their experiences were substantially genuine.

Background

The history of the Amityville house begins not with a haunting, but with a documented mass murder. On November 13, 1974, Ronald DeFeo Jr. shot and killed his parents, Ronald DeFeo Sr. and Louise DeFeo, along with his siblings Dawn DeFeo, Allison DeFeo, Marc DeFeo, and John Matthew DeFeo. DeFeo used a .35-caliber Marlin rifle. After a trial lasting roughly seven weeks, an insanity defense failed and he was convicted in November 1975 of six counts of second-degree murder. He received six sentences of 25 years to life and remained imprisoned until his death in March 2021.

The murders would later become inseparable from the paranormal legend surrounding the house, but the two histories should be kept distinct. The jury did not find that a supernatural presence caused or directed DeFeo's actions. That possibility entered the story later, as DeFeo's defense attorney, William Weber, looked for grounds on which the case might be reopened. At a February 1976 press conference, Weber suggested that the strange experiences subsequently reported by the house's new owners might have implications for DeFeo's conviction.

George Lutz and Kathleen Lutz had married in July 1975. That December they moved into the Amityville house with Kathleen's children, Daniel, Christopher, and Melissa, known as Missy. The family knew about the DeFeo murders before buying the property. They reportedly paid $80,000 for the house and an additional $400 for furniture left behind by the DeFeos.

The Lutz family moved in on December 18, 1975, and left on January 14, 1976. They later attributed their departure to increasingly disturbing experiences inside the house. Contemporary accounts, however, were not uniform. Some friends supported the claim that unusual events had frightened the family away, while another explanation was that the house had become financially difficult to maintain after its heating system failed. A mover who returned for the family's belongings shortly after their departure reported experiencing nothing unusual.

The story first reached newspaper readers in February 1976 and quickly expanded beyond the relatively limited claims available at the time. The best-known version emerged through Jay Anson's The Amityville Horror, published in 1977. Anson had not personally witnessed the alleged events in the house. He developed the book largely from extensive recorded interviews provided by the Lutzes.

The book transformed the family's account into an elaborate supernatural narrative involving cold spots, swarms of flies, unexplained odors, strange substances, damaged doors, apparent hoofprints in snow, a pig-like figure, and a concealed room in the basement. Several of those details were later challenged. Subsequent owners James Cromarty and Barbara Cromarty said that doors, locks, and windows showed no evidence of the extensive damage described in the story. The supposedly hidden "red room" was identified as an ordinary basement space. Investigators also challenged the snowy conditions required for the reported hoofprints, while neighbors reported no comparable disturbances during the Lutz family's 28-day stay. The local police likewise had no record of being summoned to the house by the family.

Other elements of the developing mythology proved similarly difficult to substantiate. Claims involving a local establishment called the Witches' Brew and a supposed Indigenous history attached to the property were disputed. These problems do not establish what the Lutz family did or did not personally experience inside the house, but they materially weaken portions of the historical narrative later built around those experiences.

The priest portrayed in Anson's account as "Father Mancuso" was Ralph J. Pecoraro. His own accounts became another point of controversy. In a televised interview, Pecoraro described encountering unexplained cold, hearing a commanding voice, and experiencing an apparent physical sensation while blessing part of the house. In an affidavit associated with subsequent litigation, however, Pecoraro gave a more limited account of his contact with the Lutz family and rejected some of the afflictions attributed to the priest in Anson's book. The two accounts do not fit comfortably together, and neither should be silently substituted for the other.

On March 6, 1976, Ed Warren and Lorraine Warren visited the empty house during an investigation attended by media personnel and others. Photographer Gene Campbell positioned an infrared camera on the second-floor landing. One photograph showed a small figure in a doorway with unusually bright eyes. The image did not become widely associated with the case until years later and has since been interpreted in different ways, including the suggestion that the figure was an investigator present during the visit and that the eye effect resulted from infrared photography. The Warrens concluded that the house was affected by a demonic presence, but that conclusion remains their interpretation rather than an independently established finding.

Credibility note on the Warrens: Ed Warren and Lorraine Warren's work has been the subject of longstanding allegations of exaggeration, fabrication, and embellished or coached details. Their involvement does not by itself invalidate other witnesses or establish that a case was fraudulent. However, claims originating with the Warrens should not be treated as independently verified without corroborating evidence.

The dispute became increasingly public as the Amityville story grew into a commercial phenomenon. In 1977, the Lutzes sued William Weber, writer Paul Hoffman, two claimed clairvoyants, and magazines involved in earlier versions of the story. Their claims were ultimately dismissed in federal court. Weber subsequently alleged publicly that the horror narrative had been developed collaboratively with the Lutzes. George Lutz continued to reject that characterization and maintained that the family's experiences were substantially true.

George and Kathleen later underwent polygraph examinations that were interpreted by the examiners as supporting their truthfulness. Those results are part of the case history, but they cannot independently establish what occurred inside the house. By then, The Amityville Horror had already become a major publishing success, and its 1979 film adaptation pushed the story still further into popular culture.

The result is a case with several distinct layers that are often blurred together: the DeFeo murders are documented history; the Lutz family did live in the house for 28 days and reported disturbing experiences; Anson transformed those claims into a bestselling narrative; investigators and later owners challenged numerous details; and key participants offered conflicting accounts of how the story developed. None of those facts requires dismissing every experience reported by the Lutz family, but neither does the historical record support treating the bestselling version of The Amityville Horror as a literal account of established events.

Witness statement

No statement on file.

Evidence & media

amityville-6
amityville-6
The Amityville House
Untitled Photo
Untitled Photo
Lutz Family

Sources

Further reading

Continue exploring — Wikipedia, documentaries, podcasts, museum pages. Not treated as proof, and not independently verified by this archive.

Investigation timeline

  • 2026-09-24 — Historical file submitted.
  • 2026-09-24 — Historical file accepted and published.
    Assigned GG-2026-042

Research notes

Historical research: Six murders are a verdict; the haunting is a story a lawyer said they invented.

The deaths are not in dispute. Ronald DeFeo Jr. was convicted of killing the other six people in that house. Everything filed here as a haunting comes from the 28 days after the Lutzes moved in, from tapes they gave a writer, and from a priest who has described that visit in two ways that exclude each other.

Weber is the person in the best position to say how the supernatural version was built, and he said he built it with them, over wine, out of real incidents moved around to make a book. Weinstein, looking at the lawsuit the Lutzes brought to protect that story, called the book largely fiction and traced it to Weber’s suggestions. The Cromartys then lived in the same rooms for about ten years. They did not find broken doors, a secret red room, or a presence. They found tourists.

The photograph does not close the gap. It was made on infrared during the Warren visit and kept back until a film needed publicity. The Warren reading of the house is suspect on its own terms until someone else corroborates it, and the later owners are the corroboration that runs the other way. The murders happened. The 28 days happened. The demon is the book.

Propose evidence & media, a source citation, further reading, a research note, a correction, a related case, or a series link. Staff review before anything is added. An accepted correction does not replace the file by itself.

Discussion