GG-2026-067
Old Arnold Estate
- Phenomenon Physical & Poltergeist Activity
- Documentation
Rating C
- A — Strong dossier: several independent sources plus primary evidence (original media, records, measurements) a researcher could use without interviewing anyone.
- B — Well documented: multiple independent witnesses with at least some contemporary primary material, or one witness with substantial primary corroboration (photos, recordings, contemporaneous notes, documents).
- C — Multi-source but soft: several witnesses or a long run of reports, but mostly testimony and after-the-fact secondary sources (newspapers, folklore collections, later interviews). Little or no primary physical evidence. Regional legend clusters such as the Bridgewater Triangle land here.
- D — Thin: single witness (or one household), little or no support beyond the account. Normal for a sincere personal experience.
- E — Incomplete or not yet assessed. Every new submission starts here until staff have read it.
- Evidence & media 2 items
- Status Historic
- Location Harrisville, Rhode Island
- Occurred 11 January 1971
This case is associated with private or restricted property. Do not trespass, disturb residents, remove artifacts, or conduct an investigation without explicit permission.
Exact marker for the Old Arnold Estate, now widely known as The Conjuring House. The marker identifies the historic property associated with the Perron family claims. The property is privately owned; visitor access depends on current tour and restoration arrangements and should not be assumed from the map marker.
Activity period
- Earliest claimed event 1971
- Earliest documented report 2011
- Latest documented report 1980
- Pattern Historic wave
Summary
Beginning in 1971, the Perron family reported years of unusual experiences in an eighteenth-century farmhouse in Harrisville, Rhode Island, now widely known as The Conjuring House. Family accounts included unexplained sounds, odors, moving objects, apparitions, and episodes they interpreted as increasingly threatening. Paranormal investigators Ed Warren and Lorraine Warren later became involved, and the case eventually inspired the 2013 film The Conjuring. The film and later paranormal literature associated the haunting with Bathsheba Sherman, a nineteenth-century woman portrayed as a witch and murderer. Historical evidence does not support those accusations or establish that Sherman caused the reported phenomena.
Background
The farmhouse associated with the Perron case stands in Harrisville, a village within Burrillville, Rhode Island. Historical material for the property dates its oldest surviving structure to 1736. Long before its global fame, it was a working New England farm associated with several generations of local families and became known as the Old Arnold Estate.
Roger Perron and Carolyn Perron moved into the farmhouse with their five daughters in January 1971. The family remained there until 1980. Their accounts of what happened during those years later became the foundation of the property's paranormal reputation.
According to later accounts from members of the Perron family, unusual experiences began relatively soon after they arrived. Reports included unexplained sounds and smells, objects apparently moving, cold areas within the house, and apparitions. Over time, some family members described experiences they regarded as increasingly aggressive, with Carolyn Perron becoming particularly prominent in later versions of the story.
These claims belong primarily to the Perron family's testimony and later retellings. They document what family members said they experienced, rather than independently establishing the cause of those experiences.
Ed Warren and Lorraine Warren eventually became involved with the property. The Warrens interpreted the case within their broader religious and demonological framework, but later popular accounts, particularly The Conjuring, gave their interpretation far greater cultural prominence than the underlying historical evidence warrants.
The most significant example is Bathsheba Sherman.
Sherman was a real nineteenth-century Rhode Island resident. Later legend accused her of witchcraft, harming or killing children, practicing Satanism, and cursing the land associated with the Perron haunting. Those accusations became central to the fictionalized version of the story.
The surviving historical record does not establish those claims. Modern historical reviews have found no support for presenting Sherman as a convicted or established witch or murderer, and one recent examination concludes that the documentary record does not even establish that Sherman lived on the Perron property itself.
That distinction fundamentally changes the historical case.
The question“Did the Perron family experience unexplained events?” cannot be answered simply by demonstrating that the Bathsheba Sherman story is historically weak.
But the question“Was Bathsheba Sherman the demonic witch haunting the Perron family?” depends upon a chain of historical claims that has not been substantiated.
The family's story later reached a much larger audience through Andrea Perron's memoirs and, most dramatically, the 2013 film The Conjuring. The film was inspired by the family's reported experiences but substantially dramatized the history and helped transform Sherman into the recognizable villain now associated with the property.
The house itself was not used as the filming location for the movie. Rather, the historic farmhouse became publicly known as “The Conjuring House” because it was the property associated with the Perron family's story.
The property's later history provides additional context. The house's own historical timeline describes decades following the Perron family's departure as comparatively quiet and distinguishes those years from the paranormal reputation subsequently created around the property. The house nevertheless became internationally famous after The Conjuring and has since been opened to visitors interested in its history and paranormal reputation.
That modern activity should not be treated as retroactive confirmation of the experiences reported by the Perrons in the 1970s. Visitor experiences and modern investigations belong to a later period of the property's history.
The Old Arnold Estate case therefore contains several layers that should remain separate:
The house: a genuine eighteenth-century Rhode Island farmhouse with a long documented history.
The Perron experiences: years of unusual events reported by family members while they lived there.
The Warren interpretation: a paranormal and religious explanation applied to those experiences.
The Bathsheba Sherman narrative: a later historical attribution containing serious unsupported claims about a real nineteenth-century woman.
The Conjuring: a fictionalized horror film inspired by portions of the preceding story.
Separating those layers does not require dismissing the Perron family's reported experiences. It prevents later folklore and cinematic invention from being used as evidence for events that allegedly occurred decades earlier.
Credibility note on the Warrens
Ed Warren and Lorraine Warren's paranormal claims and investigative methods have been disputed in multiple cases. Their involvement is historically relevant but should not be treated as independent confirmation of a supernatural explanation. Warren-originated claims require corroboration before Gothic.Black treats them as verified.
Witness statement
No statement on file.
Evidence & media

Perron House Old
This is said to be the oldest-known photo of what would become the Perron family house, taken decades before the alleged haunting.

Perron Family Haunting
The Perron family, minus Roger, in January of 1971, shortly after moving into their allegedly haunted home.
Further reading
Continue exploring — Wikipedia, documentaries, podcasts, museum pages. Not treated as proof, and not independently verified by this archive.
Investigation timeline
- 2026-09-27 — Historical file submitted.
- 2026-09-27 — Historical file accepted and published.
Assigned GG-2026-067
Research notes
Historical research: Folkloric Synthesis, Legend Building, and Media Amplification
From environmental, architectural, and sociological perspectives, the Arnold Estate case offers an opportunity to examine structural acoustics, historical building dynamics, and narrative development over time.
Built in 1736, the farmhouse features timber-frame construction, stone foundations, and uninsulated wall cavities typical of 18th-century New England rural architecture. Environmental researchers note that uninsulated wood structures undergo significant thermal contraction and expansion between seasons, producing sudden creaks, settling noises, and pressure-driven door movement that can be misconstrued as physical manipulation. Furthermore, historic homes often exhibit localized draft channels and microclimates caused by unsealed masonry basements, contributing to localized cold spots and stagnant odor pockets from decomposing pests within walls. Sociological studies on the formation of modern urban legends emphasize how historical tragedies—such as childhood mortality or sudden illness recorded in municipal land registries over two centuries—are frequently synthesized into unified local folklore when reinforced by sensationalist external observers.
Historical research: High-Density Witness Alignment and Familial Trauma Continuity
While archival records clarify the historical life of Bathsheba Sherman, parapsychological investigators focus on the high density of concordant witness testimony recorded among the household residents.
Parapsychology evaluates the site as a potential case of Recurrent Spontaneous Psychokinesis (RSPK) or environmental haunting, noting that seven independent family members (two parents and five children) independently described detailed physical anomalies. These included multi-sensory manifestations such as unexplained olfactory phenomena, physical impacts, and shared visual apparitions observed simultaneously under varied lighting conditions. Unlike typical poltergeist cases centered on a single adolescent focal agent, the Perron family reports spanned nearly a decade across multiple individuals of varying ages. Researchers examine whether specific environmental parameters—such as subterranean water flow beneath the property or localized electromagnetic fluctuations—may act as physical triggers for altered states of consciousness, or if the home hosted genuine, unclassified psychical interactions.
Open research questions
A specific gap in the file. An accepted source, research note, or further-reading link closes it.
Locate the earliest surviving contemporary records of the Perron family's reported experiences at the Old Arnold Estate, including family correspondence, photographs, interviews, newspaper coverage and Warren case material. Determine which major claims can be traced to 1971–1980 and which first appear in Andrea Perron's later memoirs, Warren accounts or subsequent media.
Propose evidence & media, a source citation, further reading, a research note, a correction, a related case, or a series link. Staff review before anything is added. An accepted correction does not replace the file by itself.