Activity period
- Earliest claimed event 1970
- Earliest documented report Unknown
- Latest documented report Ongoing
- Pattern Recurring
Summary
Boston Common (established in 1634) and the adjoining Central Burying Ground (1756) are among Boston’s most historically significant public spaces. The Common served as a pasture, military gathering ground, execution site, and civic meeting place, while the burying ground became the final resting place for thousands of Bostonians, including many who lacked access to private family tombs. Nineteenth-century street projects and the construction of Boston’s first subway lines disturbed and reinterred numerous burials, a history still marked by a memorial within the cemetery. Ghost stories involving colonial figures, execution victims, soldiers, and a mysterious child are common in local folklore and ghost tours, but remain anecdotal and unverified. The historical record is well established; the causes of the reported paranormal experiences remain unresolved.
Background
Boston Common, established in 1634, is generally regarded as the oldest public park in the United States. Over nearly four centuries it has served many roles, including common pastureland, military training ground, political gathering place, and site of public punishment. One of the most enduring historical landmarks associated with the Common was the Great Elm, which functioned for generations as Boston’s principal hanging tree. Executions carried out at or near the elm remain a central part of the Common’s history and are frequently cited in later ghost stories involving apparitions in colonial clothing, phantom hanging figures, disembodied voices, and unusual nighttime encounters. While the executions themselves are historical fact, the paranormal claims associated with them belong to later folklore.
The Common also played an important role during the American Revolution. British troops occupied and camped on the grounds during the colonial period, and military activity continued there long after independence. These documented events later contributed to stories of ghostly soldiers, marching figures, and unexplained sightings reported throughout the park and surrounding areas.
Along the Common’s southern edge lies the Central Burying Ground, established in 1756 as Boston’s fourth major cemetery. The cemetery provided burial space for many residents who lacked family plots elsewhere, including immigrants, transient residents, laborers, and the poor, though some more prominent individuals were also interred there. Among those buried in the cemetery are painter Gilbert Stuart and several individuals associated with the Boston Tea Party.
The cemetery underwent significant changes during the nineteenth century as Boston expanded. Historical records indicate that improvements to Boylston Street during the 1830s required the relocation of tombs and the reinterment of remains within the cemetery. An even larger disruption occurred in 1895 during excavation for Boston’s early subway system. Construction crews uncovered tombs and previously unknown burials beneath the area. Many of the recovered remains were consolidated into a common grave within the cemetery, marked today by a slate memorial. This marker remains one of the clearest physical reminders of the site’s long and complicated burial history.
Modern ghost stories often connect these disturbed graves to reports of paranormal activity. Some tour narratives claim that the remains uncovered during subway construction belonged to British soldiers killed during the Revolutionary era. Historical sources are more cautious. City records note that some British officers are believed to be buried in the cemetery, but no definitive evidence confirms that the remains discovered during the 1895 excavations belonged specifically to British military dead. The memorial itself refers only to remains found during subway construction rather than identifying a particular group.
Reported paranormal activity centers on both the cemetery and the surrounding Common. Witnesses have described colonial-era figures among the gravestones, shadowy forms moving between monuments, sudden feelings of unease or crowding, and apparitions resembling soldiers near the nearby transit lines. Green Line operators and transit employees have occasionally reported seeing uniformed figures near tracks or tunnel entrances, though such accounts remain anecdotal.
One of the best-known individual stories involves Boston dentist Matt Rutger, whose experience entered local ghost literature through later books rather than contemporary newspaper reporting. According to the story, Rutger encountered a silent young girl dressed in a worn white dress while walking near the cemetery during the 1970s. The figure allegedly appeared in multiple locations within a short period, interacted physically by tugging at his clothing, and disappeared without explanation. Variations of the account differ in detail, and the earliest widely available versions trace back to later paranormal publications rather than primary documentation from the time of the alleged encounter.
Today, Boston Common and the Central Burying Ground remain significant historical landmarks whose documented past is often more remarkable than the legends attached to them. Executions, military occupation, cemetery relocations, and subway excavations are all matters of historical record. The reported apparitions, shadow figures, voices, and other paranormal experiences continue to circulate through local folklore, ghost tours, and witness testimony, but none have been independently verified. As a result, the site occupies a space where well-documented history and enduring legend continue to overlap.
Witness statement
No statement on file.
Evidence & media

Granary Burying Ground.Max
Granary Burying Ground - Boston
Further reading
Continue exploring — Wikipedia, documentaries, podcasts, museum pages. Not treated as proof, and not independently verified by this archive.
Investigation timeline
- 2026-09-22 — Historical file submitted.
- 2026-09-22 — Historical file accepted and published.
Assigned GG-2026-023
Research notes
Historical research: A Case Where the History May Be More Significant Than the Ghosts
History carries this file; ghosts ride along
Documented: Common’s age and uses; Great Elm as execution site; Central’s 1756 founding and social mix; 1830s and 1895 disturbances and reinterments; city caution on British officer burials. That paper trail explains why the ground invites haunting stories without proving them.
Soft: apparitions, girl ghost, trackside soldiers, hanging specters. The Rutger/girl episode is a named anecdote preserved in secondary ghost literature — better than anonymous tour blurbs, still not contemporaneous documentation. Soldier-on-the-tracks stories sit with transit folklore.
Do not upgrade “British soldiers dug up for the T” from probable tour talk to settled ID. Use Boston.gov’s careful language.
Historical research: First paranormal claim
The earliest paranormal report currently identified by this investigation dates to the 1970s and involves an alleged apparition encounter reported by Matt Rutger. While the Common and cemetery are associated with much older historical events, no earlier documented ghost reports have yet been located. Additional newspaper, folklore, and archival research may reveal earlier claims.
Open research questions
A specific gap in the file. An accepted source, research note, or further-reading link closes it.
Trace the Matt Rutger Central Burying Ground apparition account to its earliest source and determine whether documented paranormal accounts of the cemetery predate that story.
Propose evidence & media, a source citation, further reading, a research note, a correction, a related case, or a series link. Staff review before anything is added. An accepted correction does not replace the file by itself.